An owner opens a new building, and within a year a demand letter arrives: the accessible route is too steep, the restroom clearances are short, the wheelchair seating lacks sightlines. The owner’s first call is to its lawyer. The second is usually to the architect. Whether that second call becomes a covered claim depends on federal law that is still unsettled, contracts the firm signed years earlier, and how its professional liability policy treats corrective work.
Can an architect be sued directly under the ADA?
Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act treats the failure to design and construct facilities for first occupancy that are readily accessible as discrimination. The question is who can be liable for that failure, and federal courts have split. As IRMI summarized, the Eighth Circuit and federal courts in Minnesota and Florida have applied a “significant degree of control” test that can reach an architect, while courts in Kentucky, California and the District of Columbia have limited liability to owners, lessors and operators.
The U.S. Department of Justice pressed the broader reading. In United States v. Ellerbe Becket, a federal court in Minnesota denied the firm’s motion to dismiss in 1997, holding that architects may have liability under Title III. The case ended in a 1998 consent order in which the firm, without admitting liability, agreed to design future stadium seating with comparable lines of sight for wheelchair users.
The Ninth Circuit went the other way in Lonberg v. Sanborn Theaters (2001), holding that designers are not liable under Title III unless they are also an owner, lessor or operator, because the statute’s design-and-construct language defines what counts as discrimination but not who can be sued. Until the Supreme Court resolves the split, the answer can depend on where the project sits.
Housing projects bring a different statute
Multifamily and senior housing bring the Fair Housing Act’s design and construction requirements into play, and the Justice Department has pursued architects directly. In September 2022, DOJ announced a consent order with J. Randolph Parry Architects covering eight Pennsylvania senior living facilities. It required $350,000 for retrofits, a $75,000 compensation fund and a $25,000 civil penalty under the Fair Housing Act and the ADA. The firm denied intentional discrimination.
The indirect path: owner claims against the designer
Even where direct ADA liability is doubtful, an owner sued over an inaccessible facility will often look to the designer through contract and negligence. ConstructionRisk.com observed after Lonberg that such a claim would turn on the professional standard of care rather than civil rights liability.
Some courts have closed that door too. In Equal Rights Center v. Niles Bolton Associates (4th Cir. 2010), the court held that the ADA and Fair Housing Act preempted a developer’s state-law claims against the architect for breach of contract, negligence, indemnity and contribution. An Illinois appellate court reached a similar result in Chicago Housing Authority v. DeStefano and Partners (2015), reasoning that the owner’s duty to comply is non-delegable. Preemption is a defense to be argued, not a guarantee, and it does not stop the claim from being filed.
How professional liability responds
An accessibility error is a design error, and design errors are what professional liability is built for. Commenting on the Parry settlement, Burns & Wilcox’s Tameka Livatino said A&E professional liability may cover retrofit costs and defense, while ADA penalties may fall under supplementary payments that are usually capped low. Three policy features deserve attention:
- Fines and penalties. Most definitions of damages exclude civil penalties. Check whether any regulatory sublimit exists and how large it is.
- Injunctive relief and corrective costs. A claim seeking only an injunction may not meet the policy’s definition of a claim for damages. Ask how the form treats non-monetary demands and the cost to correct.
- Contractual liability. Indemnities and warranties of code compliance can expand what you owe beyond the standard of care; our briefing on indemnification and duty to defend in design contracts explains the mechanics.
Practical steps for design firms
- Strike contract language that warrants “full compliance” with the ADA or Fair Housing Act; promise the professional standard of care instead.
- Document accessibility reviews at each phase, including owner decisions that depart from your recommendation.
- On multifamily and senior housing, consider an independent accessibility review before permit.
- Track which federal circuit a project sits in; the direct-liability answer can change with it.
- Remember that parties who never signed your contract still have routes to you; see our note on the economic loss doctrine and third-party claims.
Questions to ask your broker before renewal
- Does our policy defend an ADA or FHA action that seeks only injunctive relief?
- Is there a sublimit for regulatory fines or penalties, and what does it cover?
- How does the policy treat retrofit and corrective-design costs?
- Did any client contract we signed this year include an accessibility warranty?
At Peoples First Tennessee, we work accessibility exposure through our 4-Step Strategic Process: Strategic Discovery of your project mix, Risk Assessment of contracts and policy wording, Solution Design that aligns the two, and Ongoing Optimization as case law moves. For the full framework, see our guide to architects and engineers professional liability insurance.
— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor