For a design firm, a set of drawings is two things at once — the deliverable a client pays for and a protected creative work the firm owns. Those two identities rarely collide until a client, a successor architect, or a contractor keeps using the design after the relationship ends. When they do, the dispute lands in an area most principals assume their professional liability policy covers. Often it does not.

The law protects more than principals expect

Copyright in architecture is broader than many firms realize. In 1990, Congress passed the Architectural Works Copyright Protection Act, which added "architectural works" to the categories protected under Section 102(a)(8) of the Copyright Act. For works created on or after December 1, 1990, that protection reaches not only the plans and drawings but the overall form and the arrangement and composition of spaces in the built design itself — which means a building can infringe even when no one copied a single sheet. The remedies have teeth. One widely cited treatment of architectural copyright notes that a court may award up to $150,000 per infringement in statutory damages, along with the copyright owner's attorneys' fees and costs, when the work was registered on time. For a firm on the receiving end of that claim, defense alone is a material exposure.

Instruments of service and the license that runs with them

The contract is where ownership actually gets decided. Under AIA B101-2017, "the Architect and the Architect's consultants are deemed the authors and owners of their respective Instruments of Service" and retain all rights, including copyright. The owner receives a license — not the design — limited to using the documents "solely and exclusively for constructing, using, maintaining, altering and adding to the Project." That license is conditional. It terminates if the architect rightfully terminates the agreement for cause, which most often means the owner's failure to pay. EJCDC's engineering documents follow the same architecture: the engineer keeps ownership, the owner gets a bounded license, and reuse beyond the original project without the designer's involvement shifts the risk — and an indemnity obligation — back to the owner.

The stakes became concrete in Eberhard Architects, LLC v. Bogart Architecture, Inc., decided in the Northern District of Ohio in 2016. The architect worked under AIA B101-2007, the owner stopped paying, and the architect terminated the agreement. When the owner, contractor, and subcontractors kept building from the instruments of service, the architect sued for copyright infringement. Because the contract expressly stated that the license ends on a rightful termination for cause, the court let the infringement claims proceed against the parties still using the drawings. Nonpayment did not merely breach the contract — it extinguished the right to use the design at all.

Where professional liability often goes quiet

Here is the gap that surfaces at claim time. Standard A&E professional liability is built to answer negligence — a design error or omission that causes a third party harm. Intellectual property is a different animal, and many professional liability forms exclude or heavily sublimit copyright, trademark, and other IP infringement claims. A firm can carry a healthy limit, do nothing negligent, and still face an uncovered demand — because the allegation is that it copied or reused a protected design, not that it designed poorly. The exposure runs both directions: the firm accused of infringing another's work, and the firm whose own work was taken, each needing coverage the base policy may not supply.

Contracts and coverage have to be read together

Two levers control this exposure, and they have to move in concert. The first is the contract — defining who owns the instruments of service, the precise scope and duration of the owner's license, what happens on termination or nonpayment, and who indemnifies whom when a design is reused. The second is the policy — confirming whether IP and copyright infringement are covered, excluded, or capped, and whether any sublimit is adequate to the real exposure. A firm that negotiates strong ownership language and then carries a policy that excludes IP has protected its rights without protecting its balance sheet.

At PFTN, we work this through our four-step Strategic Process. Strategic Discovery surfaces how your contracts actually allocate design ownership and license rights; Risk Assessment tests those terms against what your professional liability policy will and will not answer; Solution Design closes the gap intentionally — endorsement, sublimit, or standalone coverage where the base form falls short; and Ongoing Optimization keeps the contract language and the coverage aligned as your project mix and the case law evolve. The firm that owns its drawings on paper and insures the dispute over them is the one in control when reuse becomes a claim.

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor