When a tornado, flood or earthquake damages a community, local officials need answers quickly: which buildings can people go back into, and which cannot? Structural engineers and architects are often the ones asked, many of them as volunteers. The Applied Technology Council’s ATC-20 procedures, written for volunteer structural engineers and building inspectors, sort buildings into green “Inspected,” yellow “Restricted Use” and red “Unsafe” placards. A placard decision made in minutes can follow a design professional for years.

What Tennessee’s statute protects

Tennessee addresses this in Tenn. Code Ann. § 62-2-109. An architect or engineer who voluntarily performs structural or building-systems inspections in good faith is protected from negligence liability for personal injury or property damage arising from that inspection — but only when every condition is met:

  • There must be a declared national, state or local natural or man-made emergency.
  • The inspection must be requested by a public safety officer or a city or county building inspector acting in an official capacity.
  • The services must be provided without compensation or expectation of compensation.
  • The inspection must take place within 90 days of the declared emergency.
  • There is no protection for gross negligence or willful misconduct.

The statute also reaches only inspections of structural integrity or nonstructural elements affecting life safety, on structures used for human habitation or owned by a public entity.

Where volunteers fall outside the protection

Real disasters do not follow statutory conditions neatly. Common ways a well-meaning professional ends up outside the shield:

  • The wrong requester. A congregation, a business owner or a neighbor asking for a look is not a public safety officer or building official.
  • Day 91. Recovery from a major event runs for months. FEMA’s major disaster declaration for Tropical Storm Helene in Tennessee was issued on October 2, 2024, for an incident period of September 26–30; rebuilding decisions continued long after any 90-day window would have closed.
  • Paid work. Once a volunteer look turns into a fee-based assessment for an owner, lender or insurer, it is ordinary professional practice.
  • Defense still costs money. Immunity is a defense to a claim, not a bar to filing one. Someone still has to pay to assert it.
  • State lines. Protection varies widely. ASCE’s Policy Statement 536, readopted by its Board in July 2026, notes that immunity ranges from wrongful death only to personal injury and property damage, lasts anywhere from 30 days to the end of the response, and often requires working with a public safety officer. The AIA’s compendium adds that these laws generally protect professionals licensed in the state where the law applies.

How your professional liability policy responds

Do not assume the firm’s professional liability policy follows an employee into volunteer work. How a policy defines “professional services,” and who counts as an insured when acting outside a firm engagement, varies by form. Ask three things in writing: whether volunteer and emergency-response services are covered, whether individual employees acting as volunteers are insureds, and whether the policy will defend while immunity is being argued.

The profession has been pressing for broader protection. ASCE observes that all 50 states and the federal government protect other first responders, while protection for engineers remains uneven, and it points to the post-9/11 World Trade Center response, where structural engineers were sued over alleged toxic exposure even though, as ASCE puts it, “No serious injury or fatality was ever linked to their work at the WTC Site.”

One subtle issue deserves counsel’s view. If a firm deploys staff on paid time, it is worth asking whether that affects the “without compensation” condition. Workers’ compensation for employees sent into damaged structures should be confirmed too.

Before the next declared emergency

  • Decide as a firm whether staff may volunteer, under whose direction and on whose time.
  • Train in a recognized evaluation procedure such as ATC-20 before an event, not during one.
  • Keep a running log for every inspection: who requested it, their title and agency, the declaration date and the inspection date.
  • Document observations and placard decisions with photographs, the same discipline described in our briefing on construction observation liability.
  • Review your policy wording with your broker and ask for written confirmation on volunteer coverage.

Severe-weather design questions raise their own standard-of-care issues; see our note on tornado wind loads and the engineer’s standard of care.

At Peoples First Tennessee, we work through disaster-response exposure with design firms using our 4-Step Strategic Process: Strategic Discovery of how your people actually respond, Risk Assessment against the statute and your policy wording, Solution Design of endorsements or written confirmations, and Ongoing Optimization as the law changes. For the fundamentals, see our guide to architects and engineers professional liability insurance.

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor