Every design firm eventually has a client who is slow to pay. The work was delivered, the invoices went out, and the balance sits unpaid for reasons that have nothing to do with the quality of the drawings. The instinct — entirely reasonable — is to send the account to collection or to a lawyer and pursue the fee that was earned. For a professional services firm, that instinct is also the single most reliable way to turn an unpaid invoice into a malpractice claim.

The mechanism is well understood by everyone who underwrites architects and engineers professional liability. A client who does not want to pay, when sued for the fee, rarely argues that the bill is wrong. The client argues that the service was deficient — that the design caused a cost overrun, that a detail was missed, that the problem on the project traces back to the firm. The fee suit becomes the occasion for a counterclaim, and the counterclaim is a professional liability claim in everything but name. The firm set out to recover a receivable and instead opened a defense file.

A claim study published by Great American put concrete numbers on the trade. A firm with a $35,000 design fee pursued roughly $22,000 in unpaid billings. The client responded with a counterclaim, and after more than a year of litigation the matter settled for a $7,500 payment to the firm in exchange for dropping the dispute. The firm had spent about $5,000 pursuing the fee and roughly $26,000 defending the counterclaim — about $31,000 in combined legal cost to recover $7,500. The study's conclusion was blunt: fee disputes often cost more than they recover.

The claim economics of 2026 make that math worse, not better. Victor's analysis of a decade of A&E claims found average severity rose roughly 62% in nominal terms comparing the 2016–2025 period with the decade before — about 19% after inflation — even as frequency held roughly flat. Design firms are not necessarily generating more claims; each claim simply costs far more to defend and resolve. Victor also found that about 32% of U.S. claims in that period closed with expense only and no payment to the claimant, yet those no-indemnity files alone generated nearly $220 million in defense and claim-adjustment cost. A counterclaim a firm is confident it will win still costs real money to win.

The front-line data tells the same story in miniature. Holmes Murphy's Data from Design report logged 25 claims and 42 pre-claim matters in the first quarter of 2026 — roughly one new matter every business day across its design-firm book — with quality-assurance and quality-control issues the most common basis for claims. The point is not that claims are surging; the first-quarter count actually fell. The point is that the environment a fee suit invites a client into is one where defending even a meritless allegation is a meaningful expense.

The discipline is to make the fee suit unnecessary, and to weigh it honestly when it is not. Clear contract terms, written change orders, and milestone or upfront billing reduce the size of any receivable before it becomes a dispute. When a client does fall behind, the AIA's own guidance is to document the firm's position in writing — particularly when a financially distressed owner begins cutting corners that raise the firm's exposure — and to treat nonpayment as a signal to tighten the file rather than to chase the balance. Before pursuing a fee, a firm should weigh the realistic recovery against the near-certain cost of the counterclaim it will provoke, and should consult its professional liability carrier, because many insurers ask to be notified before a firm sues a client precisely because of what tends to come back.

This is the judgment our 4-Step Strategic Process is built to support. Strategic Discovery reviews how the firm contracts, bills, and documents its engagements before a receivable ever ages. Risk Assessment weighs a specific unpaid fee against the exposure a collection action would open and the policy's treatment of it. Solution Design builds the billing terms, change-order discipline, and documentation practices that keep fees collectible without litigation. Ongoing Optimization keeps those practices and the carrier relationship aligned as the firm's project mix changes.

A fee that was genuinely earned feels like a matter of principle, and sometimes it is worth pursuing. But a design firm's balance sheet is far more exposed to a professional liability claim than to a written-off invoice. The firms that come through these situations best are the ones that decided, before the dispute arose, that the receivable was not worth the file it would open — and built the contract and billing discipline to keep most receivables from aging that far in the first place.

— Ryan Mefford, President & Risk Advisor